please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53

73 posts · 2007-07-13 10:55:15 to 2008-01-24 09:08:14

#36300294312 07/30/2007 23:26:06 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
I like the shiny on the burning eye trench though... beta glasses need imediate fixing :p
#36300294420 07/31/2007 07:56:03 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
I agree that the System Shades need a little toning down.  I like having some shine on them, but they appear too translucent now... I always saw them as something that should be very dark.  *shrug*
#36300295667 08/02/2007 08:34:20 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
EDIT: Wrong thread.. SMILEY
#36300295761 08/02/2007 11:03:51 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
Croesus wrote:
0rexis wrote:
Also, I wish we could get the specularity of the Agent shades toned down slightly... The shine now is nice, but I think there's just a little
"too much" of it, and it's a bit distracting. o.O


I like the shine on the System Shades, but the shine itself when looking at the character head-on goes right through the bridge of the Shades and the inside of each side, at least it does on the female version (I don't think I'm explaining it properly) I would prefer it if the shine cut across diagonally down the outside of one of the lenses when head-on. If thats not possible then I'd go withs 0rexis about the toning down of the shine.


If neither than can we at least get rid of the shine from the frames ie. the bridge and the arms, keeping them a dark colour? I am sure their textures are different to the actual lenses....


You know, I really don't mind the shinyness on the shades. I like how in the last picture it shines on the rims of the shades making it look like it was made out of metal which gives it a cool effect in my opinion.
*edited by admin*
#36300295805 08/02/2007 12:13:51 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
Ballak wrote:
Croesus wrote:


You know, I really don't mind the shinyness on the shades. I like how in the last picture it shines on the rims of the shades making it look like it was made out of metal which gives it a cool effect in my opinion.
Meh, personal preferences I suppose! The system shades, at least for women have always been quite translucent. I just think that they should be a bit darker, as Shinryu has mentioned, and with the shine at a different position when head-on, if possible, rather than down the middle (as shown)...
#36300296479 08/03/2007 23:25:35 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53

I don't have any handy before and after shots.. but I do know that my hosh boots look ... glossy...I prefer my leather to look worked and worn .. not varnished.  (and black should be black.. not grey-yellow)

#36300303849 08/15/2007 09:21:55 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53

So that is why those things are broken!  The reflections and shine is not working with Vista very well.  I posted about this in the Tech section - but now I think we have found a main reason why they aren't working.  Please bring this to light with the code writers.

Most of the female clothing destroys the graphics in the game when applied.  I bought a Green Dragon Li fighting ... thing and it's shineyness made my video completely break.  As with other dressed and female clothing articles.

 

 Sorry about the dither quality of the gif.  But this shows the problem with a reflection texture and certain articles of clothing.  Boots - long boots seem to set this off the most.  The Short shoes do not affect it.

The long boots seem to be affecting this dress.  The Richland Fighting Dress.  And probably others and may account for the bugs in the graphics of the game for Vista users.  It's a relfection texture.  Similar to the one that is on the windows of the buildings.

"Sidestrap" vs "Short"  shoes and boots do this without fail. 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Who is this doing this synthetic type of alpha beta psychedelic funky?
#36300303950 08/15/2007 12:47:15 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
Some of us have been with MxO longer than Rarebit and remember that this is the very same issue that led to the shiny textures being removed in the first place!  The shiny textures brought up all these exact same issues in the past and the "solution" was to remove them all together.  I got a real kick out of the release notes saying they were turned back on, especially with the optimistic tone of "we found something broken and fixed it, yay!"  Some of us saw this coming.  [mild_sarcasm] Throw out the baby with the bathwater, solve the problem by nerfing the feature; it saves time.[/mild_sarcasm]  You have the same choice the Monolith dev team had:  fix it if you can or remove it if you can't or if you can't spare the time to fix it.  I hope other issues can get their own thread and we can all work together to make MxO as feature-rich and bug-free as possible.

P.S. Darkhawk, yes when an RSI dons high or medium boots, the clothing texture in use "scrunches up" from the ankles to the waist.


#36300304071 08/15/2007 15:55:40 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
PS10N wrote:
Some of us have been with MxO longer than Rarebit and remember that this is the very same issue that led to the shiny textures being removed in the first place!  The shiny textures brought up all these exact same issues in the past and the "solution" was to remove them all together.  I got a real kick out of the release notes saying they were turned back on, especially with the optimistic tone of "we found something broken and fixed it, yay!"  Some of us saw this coming.  [mild_sarcasm] Throw out the baby with the bathwater, solve the problem by nerfing the feature; it saves time.[/mild_sarcasm]  You have the same choice the Monolith dev team had:  fix it if you can or remove it if you can't or if you can't spare the time to fix it.  I hope other issues can get their own thread and we can all work together to make MxO as feature-rich and bug-free as possible.

P.S. Darkhawk, yes when an RSI dons high or medium boots, the clothing texture in use "scrunches up" from the ankles to the waist.


Cool, if you've been here as long as me, you'll remember the fun old times back when we had character issues like this



The ubershine on certain clothing types has been adjusted and I expect will be making it out in the next update, although that's never in stone until we see it in the official patch notes.

Please note that the texture corruption issue reported by Darkhawk above is Vista-specific (I double-checked those particular dress and shoe combinations just now in XP and they're fine there), probably not directly related to specific specularity levels, and has already been noted by him and other users in the "Vista Issues" tech support thread located here:

http://forums.station.sony.com/mxo/...145#36300303889
#36300304078 08/15/2007 16:03:49 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
Rarebit wrote:
PS10N wrote:
Some of us have been with MxO longer than Rarebit and remember that this is the very same issue that led to the shiny textures being removed in the first place!  The shiny textures brought up all these exact same issues in the past and the "solution" was to remove them all together.  I got a real kick out of the release notes saying they were turned back on, especially with the optimistic tone of "we found something broken and fixed it, yay!"  Some of us saw this coming.  [mild_sarcasm] Throw out the baby with the bathwater, solve the problem by nerfing the feature; it saves time.[/mild_sarcasm]  You have the same choice the Monolith dev team had:  fix it if you can or remove it if you can't or if you can't spare the time to fix it.  I hope other issues can get their own thread and we can all work together to make MxO as feature-rich and bug-free as possible.

P.S. Darkhawk, yes when an RSI dons high or medium boots, the clothing texture in use "scrunches up" from the ankles to the waist.


Cool, if you've been here as long as me, you'll remember the fun old times back when we had character issues like this



The ubershine on certain clothing types has been adjusted and I expect will be making it out in the next update, although that's never in stone until we see it in the official patch notes.

Please note that the texture corruption issue reported by Darkhawk above is Vista-specific (I double-checked those particular dress and shoe combinations just now in XP and they're fine there), probably not directly related to specific specularity levels, and has already been noted by him and other users in the "Vista Issues" tech support thread located here:

http://forums.station.sony.com/mxo/...145#36300303889
Oh-oh my......

GF, nice 1 v 1, all me son!
#36300304149 08/15/2007 17:05:00 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
Rarebit wrote:
PS10N wrote:
Some of us have been with MxO longer than Rarebit and remember that this is the very same issue that led to the shiny textures being removed in the first place!  The shiny textures brought up all these exact same issues in the past and the "solution" was to remove them all together.  I got a real kick out of the release notes saying they were turned back on, especially with the optimistic tone of "we found something broken and fixed it, yay!"  Some of us saw this coming.  [mild_sarcasm] Throw out the baby with the bathwater, solve the problem by nerfing the feature; it saves time.[/mild_sarcasm]  You have the same choice the Monolith dev team had:  fix it if you can or remove it if you can't or if you can't spare the time to fix it.  I hope other issues can get their own thread and we can all work together to make MxO as feature-rich and bug-free as possible.

P.S. Darkhawk, yes when an RSI dons high or medium boots, the clothing texture in use "scrunches up" from the ankles to the waist.


Cool, if you've been here as long as me, you'll remember the fun old times back when we had character issues like this









O_o
#36300304151 08/15/2007 17:05:52 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
I must have you confused with someone else SMILEY  Though, in all fairness, I was in the top 100 to get an account on the Ubisoft forums back before MxO was with Monolith.

Thanks for that pic, it just bumped the leading "oldest MxO screenshot" off the top of the list, and it's been in first place for quite some time now!

#36300304816 08/16/2007 19:40:02 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
Rarebit wrote:
PS10N wrote:
Some of us have been with MxO longer than Rarebit and remember that this is the very same issue that led to the shiny textures being removed in the first place!  The shiny textures brought up all these exact same issues in the past and the "solution" was to remove them all together.  I got a real kick out of the release notes saying they were turned back on, especially with the optimistic tone of "we found something broken and fixed it, yay!"  Some of us saw this coming.  [mild_sarcasm] Throw out the baby with the bathwater, solve the problem by nerfing the feature; it saves time.[/mild_sarcasm]  You have the same choice the Monolith dev team had:  fix it if you can or remove it if you can't or if you can't spare the time to fix it.  I hope other issues can get their own thread and we can all work together to make MxO as feature-rich and bug-free as possible.

P.S. Darkhawk, yes when an RSI dons high or medium boots, the clothing texture in use "scrunches up" from the ankles to the waist.


Cool, if you've been here as long as me, you'll remember the fun old times back when we had character issues like this



The ubershine on certain clothing types has been adjusted and I expect will be making it out in the next update, although that's never in stone until we see it in the official patch notes.

Please note that the texture corruption issue reported by Darkhawk above is Vista-specific (I double-checked those particular dress and shoe combinations just now in XP and they're fine there), probably not directly related to specific specularity levels, and has already been noted by him and other users in the "Vista Issues" tech support thread located here:

http://forums.station.sony.com/mxo/...145#36300303889
Ugh... Can anyone in the office be bothered to make a mod for us to use this UI instead of the current? Its just so much more Matrixy to some of us. SMILEY
#36300313010 08/29/2007 06:06:12 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53

Please note that the texture corruption issue reported by Darkhawk above is Vista-specific (I double-checked those particular dress and shoe combinations just now in XP and they're fine there), probably not directly related to specific specularity levels, and has already been noted by him and other users in the "Vista Issues" tech support thread located here:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here's a few tips Rarebit:

Try updating your development system to Vista and get off XP immediately!  Then maybe you can see what the rest of us are experiencing.  I don't care about your working preferences are, or your personal stubbornness to use Vista.  XP is outdated and being phased out.  DON'T BE SO STUBBORN ABOUT IT!!  As a developer you should be working with the most recent technologies available.  If you work in Vista then you will be better able to catch the problems and report them to your engineers and they will be better able to find and fix the bugs. Like I said - you cannot do your job in XP and expect users to all play in outdated OSs and with outdated cards.  GET IT STRAIGHT and do what you are supposed to do!  It's not your job to turn your nose up at Vista and then use it as and excuse for all the faults you caused. 

And texture artist is not your forte'.  I don't like the recolor job your did on the black suits. They are far too black and lack highlights and the subtle bits they had before then.  They are pretty much ruined.  They are flat, lifeless and don't mix well with the environment around them.  A texture artist is supposed to use depth, color, environmental unity, realism, blending, texture feel and appearance.   Like I pointed out before in the update discussion thread about the glasses.  You put too much way too much shine on everything.  And you used broken textures and reflections that where not meant to be used.  Put it back the way it was and stop messing with things that weren't meant to be used in the first place.   And if you cannot or will not adhere or learn these things then I will suggest that they look into getting a new artist who can adapt and work with Vista and problem solve.

 It's not about what YOU want.  It's about what the customer wants.  That is the first and foremost lesson you apparently need to learn.  We pay $15.00 dollars a month to play a broken, outdated game that doesn't need anymore things going wrong with it.  And certainly not developers whom refuse to use the newest systems simply because they think they don't need to.  That fact outrages me the most about you.    "Oh well, She's using Vista ..." ... gawd!  Do your job and stop making excuses.

#36300313024 08/29/2007 06:37:43 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
Darkhawk wrote:

Please note that the texture corruption issue reported by Darkhawk above is Vista-specific (I double-checked those particular dress and shoe combinations just now in XP and they're fine there), probably not directly related to specific specularity levels, and has already been noted by him and other users in the "Vista Issues" tech support thread located here:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here's a few tips Rarebit:

Try updating your development system to Vista and get off XP immediately!  Then maybe you can see what the rest of us are experiencing.  I don't care about your working preferences are, or your personal stubbornness to use Vista.  XP is outdated and being phased out.  DON'T BE SO STUBBORN ABOUT IT!!  As a developer you should be working with the most recent technologies available.  If you work in Vista then you will be better able to catch the problems and report them to your engineers and they will be better able to find and fix the bugs. Like I said - you cannot do your job in XP and expect users to all play in outdated OSs and with outdated cards.  GET IT STRAIGHT and do what you are supposed to do!  It's not your job to turn your nose up at Vista and then use it as and excuse for all the faults you caused. 

And texture artist is not your forte'.  I don't like the recolor job your did on the black suits. They are far too black and lack highlights and the subtle bits they had before then.  They are pretty much ruined.  They are flat, lifeless and don't mix well with the environment around them.  A texture artist is supposed to use depth, color, environmental unity, realism, blending, texture feel and appearance.   Like I pointed out before in the update discussion thread about the glasses.  You put too much way too much shine on everything.  And you used broken textures and reflections that where not meant to be used.  Put it back the way it was and stop messing with things that weren't meant to be used in the first place.   And if you cannot or will not adhere or learn these things then I will suggest that they look into getting a new artist who can adapt and work with Vista and problem solve.

 It's not about what YOU want.  It's about what the customer wants.  That is the first and foremost lesson you apparently need to learn.  We pay $15.00 dollars a month to play a broken, outdated game that doesn't need anymore things going wrong with it.  And certainly not developers whom refuse to use the newest systems simply because they think they don't need to.  That fact outrages me the most about you.    "Oh well, She's using Vista ..." ... gawd!  Do your job and stop making excuses.


If Rarebit does use Vista, how on earth is he going to do his job properly if it keeps mashing to graphics to bits.  It isn't his job to report bugs, there is a whole techincal team who will have MxO installed on Vista machines and are looking at solving it, same with the Nvidia lag problem.

Those shines were not broken, they were just not rendering, they were supposed to be used.

Rarebit isn't doing what HE wants, he is doing what he can to cater for the hundereds of people who play this game, thats why some the shine/discoloration was removed/fixed as part of the last patch.

Rarebit takes screens of Live Events as a recap for people who couldn't attend, as far as I know this isn't in his job description but he does it anyway, not only that but he needs a system that will not mash the graphics as part of this, I am sure that once the Vista issue is solved (if ever) he will start using it.

#36300313895 08/30/2007 12:00:51 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
Darkhawk wrote:

Please note that the texture corruption issue reported by Darkhawk above is Vista-specific (I double-checked those particular dress and shoe combinations just now in XP and they're fine there), probably not directly related to specific specularity levels, and has already been noted by him and other users in the "Vista Issues" tech support thread located here:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here's a few tips Rarebit:

Try updating your development system to Vista and get off XP immediately!  Then maybe you can see what the rest of us are experiencing.  I don't care about your working preferences are, or your personal stubbornness to use Vista.  XP is outdated and being phased out.  DON'T BE SO STUBBORN ABOUT IT!!  As a developer you should be working with the most recent technologies available.  If you work in Vista then you will be better able to catch the problems and report them to your engineers and they will be better able to find and fix the bugs. Like I said - you cannot do your job in XP and expect users to all play in outdated OSs and with outdated cards.  GET IT STRAIGHT and do what you are supposed to do!  It's not your job to turn your nose up at Vista and then use it as and excuse for all the faults you caused. 

And texture artist is not your forte'.  I don't like the recolor job your did on the black suits. They are far too black and lack highlights and the subtle bits they had before then.  They are pretty much ruined.  They are flat, lifeless and don't mix well with the environment around them.  A texture artist is supposed to use depth, color, environmental unity, realism, blending, texture feel and appearance.   Like I pointed out before in the update discussion thread about the glasses.  You put too much way too much shine on everything.  And you used broken textures and reflections that where not meant to be used.  Put it back the way it was and stop messing with things that weren't meant to be used in the first place.   And if you cannot or will not adhere or learn these things then I will suggest that they look into getting a new artist who can adapt and work with Vista and problem solve.

 It's not about what YOU want.  It's about what the customer wants.  That is the first and foremost lesson you apparently need to learn.  We pay $15.00 dollars a month to play a broken, outdated game that doesn't need anymore things going wrong with it.  And certainly not developers whom refuse to use the newest systems simply because they think they don't need to.  That fact outrages me the most about you.    "Oh well, She's using Vista ..." ... gawd!  Do your job and stop making excuses.


Save your $15.  No one is forcing you to play a "broken, outdated game".  If you choose to pay and play, then you accept the circumstances and the environment provided.  You're not paying $15 a month for "A Matrix experience of the highest caliber using state-of-the-art technology conceptualized only by the most creative geniuses in the Universe". 

Anyone who has been in the industry long enough knows that the only thing you get by jumping the gun and buying the shiniest, newest software is a handful of problems.  Case in point.  You may be l33t for having Vista but I'm sitting lmao at the fact that on my XP OS, my graphics are superb.

#36300314149 08/30/2007 17:52:10 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
Garu wrote:
Darkhawk wrote:

Please note that the texture corruption issue reported by Darkhawk above is Vista-specific (I double-checked those particular dress and shoe combinations just now in XP and they're fine there), probably not directly related to specific specularity levels, and has already been noted by him and other users in the "Vista Issues" tech support thread located here:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here's a few tips Rarebit:

Try updating your development system to Vista and get off XP immediately!  Then maybe you can see what the rest of us are experiencing.  I don't care about your working preferences are, or your personal stubbornness to use Vista.  XP is outdated and being phased out.  DON'T BE SO STUBBORN ABOUT IT!!  As a developer you should be working with the most recent technologies available.  If you work in Vista then you will be better able to catch the problems and report them to your engineers and they will be better able to find and fix the bugs. Like I said - you cannot do your job in XP and expect users to all play in outdated OSs and with outdated cards.  GET IT STRAIGHT and do what you are supposed to do!  It's not your job to turn your nose up at Vista and then use it as and excuse for all the faults you caused. 

And texture artist is not your forte'.  I don't like the recolor job your did on the black suits. They are far too black and lack highlights and the subtle bits they had before then.  They are pretty much ruined.  They are flat, lifeless and don't mix well with the environment around them.  A texture artist is supposed to use depth, color, environmental unity, realism, blending, texture feel and appearance.   Like I pointed out before in the update discussion thread about the glasses.  You put too much way too much shine on everything.  And you used broken textures and reflections that where not meant to be used.  Put it back the way it was and stop messing with things that weren't meant to be used in the first place.   And if you cannot or will not adhere or learn these things then I will suggest that they look into getting a new artist who can adapt and work with Vista and problem solve.

 It's not about what YOU want.  It's about what the customer wants.  That is the first and foremost lesson you apparently need to learn.  We pay $15.00 dollars a month to play a broken, outdated game that doesn't need anymore things going wrong with it.  And certainly not developers whom refuse to use the newest systems simply because they think they don't need to.  That fact outrages me the most about you.    "Oh well, She's using Vista ..." ... gawd!  Do your job and stop making excuses.


Save your $15.  No one is forcing you to play a "broken, outdated game".  If you choose to pay and play, then you accept the circumstances and the environment provided.  You're not paying $15 a month for "A Matrix experience of the highest caliber using state-of-the-art technology conceptualized only by the most creative geniuses in the Universe". 

Anyone who has been in the industry long enough knows that the only thing you get by jumping the gun and buying the shiniest, newest software is a handful of problems.  Case in point.  You may be l33t for having Vista but I'm sitting lmao at the fact that on my XP OS, my graphics are superb.

The fact of the matter is that Vista is now a widely used operation system that is starting to phase out XP. New players will be using Vista most likely...since it works with y'know...every other game, so I don't think that we need one more thing holding us back. We should be catering to the needs of a (hopefully) evolving player base. This is the kind of thing that we should be hyped to change as soon as possible.
#36300314357 08/31/2007 05:38:40 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53

Good point.

I don't have a problem with them upgrading MxO to work better with Vista.  I was moreorless ticked that someone is going to the length of chewing Rarebit out like that.  Honestly, Vista compatibility is the LEAST of the concerns for this game, imho.

#36300314390 08/31/2007 06:56:30 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
Just because Vista is the latest OS that Bill Gates personal monkey slaves produced does not mean that Rarebit has to use it. If Rarebit was using Vista I would be extremely amazed (and scared for the stability of MxO)

I bought Vista on a new PC, ran it for 2 weeks and got fed up with it's slow response time, stupid display and the fact that it turned my computer into an insecure emo. Afterwards I installed XP and it's a heck of a lot better. Simple thing I'm trying to say is Vista < XP and I'm sorry that you spent £250 on an OS that has a brilliant front cover but the fact of the matter is that the problem lies within Vista, not XP. Rarebit is trying to fix the issues with Vista which is more than I'd do.

/rant stop
#36300314414 08/31/2007 07:42:30 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53
I think they point they were trying to make is that now that Vista is out for better of worse, it is the OS that is being supplied with new PC's. So a new gamer gets a flashy new PC and happens to try MxO and what do they get for their attempt to play? A lot of glitches.

I've heard that it is a problem with Vista, a problem with DirectX 10 (as part of Vista) I've also heard that its a problem with the coding of MxO. I have no idea if it is a problem with just one of them or a combination, but if SoE doesn't want MxO to go down the pan, they need to have someone look at it if they haven't got someone looking at it already. This includes the problem with the nVidia 8000 series cards.

What ever the case, a good business practise would be to have at least 1 PC running Vista just to do the QA checks for those running Vista, again they may already be doing this. Using the Dev software on XP shouldn't be a problem as long as it's checked with Vista also. Any problems on any OS with regards to disruptive graphical glitches, indeed and glitch that interferes with the running of the client should be a high priority fix.

Personally I am sticking with XP until Vista gets SP2 or equivalent, or I find something better....
#36300328250 09/24/2007 07:31:05 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53

Black Silk Collar Shirt. (all female silk collar shirts are effected, these have shine built
into the texture they don't need extra spec, alot of the time the black looks dark green)

Archived image unavailable: clothingSpec01_blackSilkCollarShirt.html


Black Consular Midriff Blouse. when camera or self moving it looks rubbery like the Squad Leaders shirt.
This fabric however does not require shine. The black looks grey at the moment.

Archived image unavailable: clothingSpec02_blackConsularMidriffBlouse.html


shown here, Red Milleri Silk Peacock Silk Tailcoat & Gold Milleri Silk Keyline Silk Tailcoat
Some of the tailcoats have visible shine, might want to check the intensity of that, or turn it off for the soft materials.

Archived image unavailable: clothingSpec03_tailcoatsALL.html





#36300392565 01/24/2008 09:08:14 Re:please list clothing with inappropriate specularity in update 53


Blocker Shades used to look a lot better.  They look too fake and plasticy now.