The General - a question

19 posts · 2007-03-28 13:02:45 to 2007-05-03 04:29:53

#36300199506 03/28/2007 13:02:45 The General - a question
This has been bugging me for a while now so I thought I'd ask folks if you have any idea

If the General was the leader of the Sentinel Army that attacked Zion, how come he wasn't fried by the Mjolnir's EMP?

I've had a few other thoughts on the matter, but I'll leave it at that for now.
#36300199517 03/28/2007 13:14:00 Re:The General - a question
I thought it was all one army, and the one at the end was just the "second wave". Maybe he was hiding out until that point, as the strategic leader.
Because it was also him who got the order to retire, and that was after the EMP.

Then again, it was hinted that he was the one hunting Niobe through the tunnels?
#36300199573 03/28/2007 13:55:14 Re:The General - a question
The General was the OS for the Sentinels as a whole. He is not one sentinel, but he controls them all. Each commando we see, they are individual sentinels
#36300199575 03/28/2007 13:57:53 Re:The General - a question
Yeah Generals throughout history tend not to get involved in the fighting but make orders from a safe distance. And anyway if he was knocked out by the EMP there would be no-one to command the sentinels who were about to destroy Zion before being ordered to stop.
Info Blog
#36300199992 03/29/2007 00:23:23 Re:The General - a question
OK, this is what kinda gets me, it could well be that the General led the army that was forced to stop, and that would actually make sense from some of the dialogue we've had from him. But then that makes him the leader of the reserve army that the machines managed to scrounge together when the EMP knocked out their main army - which doesn't exactly make him top of the pile when it comes to leadership!!

There's nothing to stop it making sense, it just doesn't quite fit in my mind
#36300205158 04/03/2007 11:15:51 Re:The General - a question

Again, you're thinking of him as the single entity that he is in the Matrix. In the real he controlled ALL of the Sentinels. You're hung up on the fact that he mentioned being two places at nearly the same time, that's because as a program, he WAS everywhere. He saw what every sentinel saw and told them what to do. He as a program chased Niobe through the tunnels, but through the Sentinels that were there. He was also guiding the sentinels through the attack of Zion, both waves. However, there is nothing to suggest that he is physically there or that he had a body to start off with.

He was the CPU of the Sentinels, he gave them orders and received all the information they received. He is the brain of the Sentinels, ALL of them. He does not control just waves or battallions, he controls all of them at the same time.

Ok, here's the simple version.

General controls and sees what the Sentinels do, Sentinels do it. General is not a sentinel (as far as we know)

#36300207188 04/05/2007 15:03:21 Re:The General - a question

It's been mentioned that he is a single entity outside of the Matrix.

"What about the General?" ~Player

"Oh, that old warship?" ~Oracle.

*edited by admin*
#36300207325 04/05/2007 17:32:23 Re:The General - a question
I've heard people reffered to as axes or battleships before, so that's slightly inconclusive
#36300207449 04/05/2007 21:24:51 Re:The General - a question
Another perspective:

Ballak wrote:

It's been mentioned that he is a single entity outside of the Matrix.

"What about the General?" ~Player

"Oh, that old warship?" ~Oracle.

This of course is After he's gone rogue.
No longer a part of the Machine whole.
While commanding the Sentinels he was part of the Machine system and needed to control, yes the sentinels attacking Zion and chasing Niobe, but also the ones defending 01 from Neo and Trinity.

After he refused to follow orders he became an exile
-- his sentience as part of the whole was cut off, and then only existed in (an) individual sentinel(s), giving him a physical 'body' in the Real.  At that point it would be more efficient and effective to centralize his consciousness in one body as he would no longer have the ability to instantly transfer information to/from every sentinel at once.



#36300220148 04/21/2007 12:54:47 Re:The General - a question
his goals differ from the others
#36300220414 04/21/2007 19:50:33 Re:The General - a question

there are 2 schools of leadership into combat, there is the alexander the great school of thought where riding into battle along with your men inspires them, and then there is the second school of thought where the "important people" need to distance themselves from the fighting to properly command (also known as the *CENSORED* commander school of thought)

the machines really did need motivation to attack and destroy zion, plus the general did not get zapped in the emp, so we can assess that the general believes in the latter school of thought

so, such a massive battle, the general was likely in zero one in a bunker

#36300220886 04/22/2007 09:25:38 Re:The General - a question

EMP's do not have infinite range.  It would be easy for the Machines to send in some sentinels and let Zion use up all their EMP's on them, and then attack with another wave of sentinels.

Illyria

#36300221254 04/22/2007 16:14:48 Re:The General - a question
Shadow Griever wrote:
The General was the OS for the Sentinels as a whole. He is not one sentinel, but he controls them all. Each commando we see, they are individual sentinels


He is the War Program, and nothing else. He is the collective consciousness of ALL of the Sentinels, or at least the central brain of them all. It could be said that when the Deus Ex Machina accepted Neo's offer of peace that the signal was immediately relayed to "The General" and from there it trickled down into the other Sentinels.

The General probably doesn't even have a location outside of the Matrix. He travels between all of the Sentinels, within pico-seconds.

    "The End is Near, the Time is Now." | W4rbl4de | Reviled Restoration-CYPHERITES
#36300222202 04/23/2007 15:44:48 Re:The General - a question

Allow me to remove some of the confusion in this thread.

Think of The General as a strategist and commander.  I've never seen any evidence to support him being the consciousness for sentinals.  He designed the attack against Zion based on the previous successful attacks he lead against them and his knowledge gained from studying the historic wars of men.  Elements of his strategy that can be seen in the attack are the use of different waves of sentinals and using the drills.  He didn't need to be on the battlefield, he just commanded the army.

The Commandos or sentinals are not "controlled" by him, but they follow his orders.  As you can plainly see for yourself in the last cinematic.

When Dues Ex Machina sent a command to the General to stop the attack, (an attack that was assured success) he refused and was removed from his position.  He went into exile along with all of the sentinals that would follow him.

#36300222551 04/23/2007 20:12:25 Re:The General - a question
ZaneZavin wrote:

Allow me to remove some of the confusion in this thread.

Think of The General as a strategist and commander.  I've never seen any evidence to support him being the consciousness for sentinals.  He designed the attack against Zion based on the previous successful attacks he lead against them and his knowledge gained from studying the historic wars of men.  Elements of his strategy that can be seen in the attack are the use of different waves of sentinals and using the drills.  He didn't need to be on the battlefield, he just commanded the army.

The Commandos or sentinals are not "controlled" by him, but they follow his orders.  As you can plainly see for yourself in the last cinematic.

When Dues Ex Machina sent a command to the General to stop the attack, (an attack that was assured success) he refused and was removed from his position.  He went into exile along with all of the sentinals that would follow him.

He is software. I'd argue that he is hardwired into each and every Sentinel, with no central location. The onl physicaly representation there is of this War Program would be The General we see in the Matrix and that's not even physical.
    "The End is Near, the Time is Now." | W4rbl4de | Reviled Restoration-CYPHERITES
#36300222668 04/23/2007 23:21:41 Re:The General - a question
Do you base this all off of the "animating program" note or do you have anything else to support this?
#36300225936 04/27/2007 15:46:21 Re:The General - a question
I decided to see what Rarebit thought.

Rarebit wrote:
ZaneZavin wrote:
Does The General have a "shell" in the real?
I guess I tend to think of him as having one, since he was a Sentinel and all.


#36300229359 05/03/2007 00:14:39 Re:The General - a question
ZaneZavin wrote:
I decided to see what Rarebit thought.

Rarebit wrote:
ZaneZavin wrote:
Does The General have a "shell" in the real?
I guess I tend to think of him as having one, since he was a Sentinel and all.


i'm adding "the general is in every single sentinel, ever" to my pile of "stuff that people just make up somewhere regarding the matrix", along with "everyone lives in 1999" and "the matrix is just one city".

then i'm going to continue jumping up and down on the sack that I've piled all those ideas into. i may kick it a bit at some point later on in the day.
#36300229401 05/03/2007 04:29:53 Re:The General - a question
betaprimus wrote:

(also known as the *CENSORED* commander school of thought)


    Don't make me smack you around a bit. =p
    The tactic of staying behind your front lines makes plenty of sense from a tactical standpoint, since if you win one battle but DIE in it, you'll just be leaving your "victorious" soldiers to fend for the rest of the war without a leader.